May 3, 2007

Donald & David 02/14/04

SFGate.com from article in SF Chronicle 02/13/07
Chronicle photo by Lacy Atkins: Mayor Gavin Newsom being thanked by Donald Bird for letting him and his partner of 40 years, David Young, marry three years ago. (article by Wyatt Buchanan)

On May 4th Donald and I had a nice phone conversation about his wedding ceremony in City Hall on Valentine's Day 2004. What was really inspiring though was to hear how he was moved by all the couples he met--while waiting 5 hours in line--to become an active part of the marriage equality movement.

Three days before Valentine’s Day Donald & David heard that San Francisco City Hall would be giving marrying gay couples. On February 14 they went over to City Hall with a friend and waited in line for 5 hours…

Donald was struck by his experience in line. There were all kinds of couples waiting to get married. Some had kids, others didn’t, and some had their families waiting with them. … Near them were a lesbian couple who had brought their kids as well as enough games and food to keep the little ones occupied all day, the moms even brought a play pen for naps—and never once during those five hours were the kids a problem
He says it was a “beautiful wait.”

Once inside City Hall Donald described it as crowded, noisy, and joyful. Dozens of couples were getting married at the same time—on every floor, in every spot. It was “beautiful chaos.”

When it came time for Donald & David to declare their vows (even though they have now been together for 41years) they were both very nervous. I asked him why they originally decided to get married after all these years: he told me that at first they wanted to make a political statement, but as it turned out it was a very emotional experience. Even though they couldn’t hear every word it all sounded fine—they agreed to be together, and having their friend Sharon witness their commitment made it even more special. He said marriage is the greatest commitment two people can make, because it is recognized by society.

For the next week or so Donald showed up every day to support & encourage couples as they waited in line. He handed out Hershey’s Kisses—offering kisses as they waited in line “committed-ly.”

One day he met a gay couple from New York City who flew in to get married, waited from 11am to 7pm, but the doors locked before they got inside. This was before City Hall started making appointments. They came to Donald, who had no official connection to City Hall, pleading to him for help. At first Donald told him that he couldn’t do anything, but they approached him again and he felt compelled to try.

He banged on the front door until a security guard showed up. After explaining the couples’ situation the guard brought David to Mark Leno (CA state assembly member for 13th district). Finally the couple was let in and married. The men were so grateful they sent Donald a “thank-you” card & asked him if they could mention him in a speech they were going to give during New York’s Gay Pride Parade. He said “yes” of course.

Eventually Donald decided he wanted to marry people. City Hall appointed him to a deputy position during the final weeks of the marriages. It was a little less hectic by then because people could finally make appointments. Donald worked from 8am to 5pm over the following weeks, marrying over 220 couples. It was “the most exciting time of my life.” He came home every day and David would tell him that he had never seen him so “happy, up, joyful”…

Toward the end of this period people came prepared. Couples brought their own vows, which he would mesh together with the official ones. Other couples brought their families and included their children in the ceremony. The 2nd to last day a lesbian couple brought 30 guests, a poet, a mandolin player, as well as recorded music.

On the last day Donald’s car fell stopped working on the way to City Hall. He called his mechanic who said the car had to go in for extensive repairs. Worried, Donald explained where he had to be and his mechanic (who is straight—married with two kids) gave him a ride in his truck to City Hall. Once he got there he found out it was the last day.

But the story doesn’t stop there. Many of the marriage he performed have become parts of documentaries chronicling the period in San Francisco when queer couples were treated as full citizens.
> Marry Me: Stories from the San Francisco Weddings (director Eli Brown)
> Flowers from the Heartland
> Pursuit of Happiness (by Mayor Newsom’s ex-brother-in-law, coming out June ’07)
> Even a program on German TV
His involvement has also given him the opportunity to share his experience at the law firm that is representing couples who are fighting in court for their right to marry. There he met Bill Clinton and his former Secretary of State Warren Christopher.

Donald continues to have confidence in Mark Leno and his bill for Marriage Equality—since his bill is expected to pass, and the only roadblock to it being made into law is Arnold Schwarzenegger—they are now organizing a group of people to talk to the Governor.

Kati & Esther's Wedding

August 4 we saw each other again at Ezeiza Airport in Buenos Aires. I [Esther] had arrived 2 hours before her, after traveling from Asunción (Paraguay) for 20 hours on the bus. I ran to buy her flowers, then wait for my bride who was arriving from the U.S.

We got married August 8th in a feminist book store.

Kati read me a poem by Pablo Neruda, and she expressed her love and commitment by reading something she had written herself.

I read a bible verse, John 10:28 to her, first from a Spanish bible, then an English one, then one in Guarani (the indigenous language of Paraguay.) That verse expressed my confidence that we really are safe in Jesus' hands.

At the beginning of our relationship, we thought that God would separate us, but we realized that it was God who brought us together.

My love is real no matter what, but I wanted to show it publicly, I wanted to share my feelings with my community.

Kati’s thoughts: I can't conceive of a type of love that doesn't include commitment. It's a good reminder that the real definition of love isn't "pretty pink feelings and butterflies in your tummy" but rather an un-self-centeredness that makes our commitment the priority. A wedding is a fun party to celebrate our love and commitment, but the real point is that I’m promising to care for someone as much as I care about myself, and that is huge.

Kati & Esther's Story (how they got to the wedding)


September 2004 I [Esther] was working as a kind of campus pastor in my country, Paraguay, when I saw Kati for the first time in an international meeting. She was a campus pastor in Chile, we were good friends first, living in different countries we only saw each other 2 or 3 times a year, but slowly we recognized that we felt something different than just friendship for each other. We felt horrible because we felt that God didn't accept our relationship, so we decided to try and cut off all communication in April 2005. We lived through months and months of suffering, hiding our feelings from everyone, then we began to really study the Bible verses that are commonly used against homosexuality, and we realized that it IS possible to be GLBT and Christian.
At that point that we got in contact and decided to take a trip to Buenos Aires to see each other. Kati told her boss in Chile that she didn’t believe any longer that homosexuality was a sin, and was fired. After 13 months of not seeing each other, we were together for 5 days in May 2006, and I realized that I couldn't live without her. We found a Christian community in Buenos Aires, and a pastor who wanted to bless our relationship. Then I had to go back to Paraguay—while Kati went back to Chile to sell her furniture and say goodbye to the students before returning home to the States.




May 2, 2007

K & B's Wedding

K. was kind enough to share the vows she and B. created for their ceremony.

These were our wedding vows. We said them back and forth as a dialogue.

K) My princess, I stand before you today. I have traveled across oceans of time seeking the heart that calls me.

B) My prince, I stand before you on this day, many years past the cornfield of my birth, where I lay dreaming of the fairy tale prince who searched for me.

K) Many years I have searched

B) Many years I dreamed

K) Sunset bleeds dreaming into night, dawn again bleeds into day. Sunlight I will never see in the language of your eyes. Yet all the blue skies and clouds that tumble by are meaningless against midnight in your arms.

B) When I first saw you, sunset lit your eyes and I saw the prince no one else would see. I knew that you were someone special, and that I loved you. All that mattered was midnight in your arms. Although the path we walked has led us often apart, I realized you were always with me, soul to soul and heart to heart. My soul mate.

K) We have many roads to walk. The labyrinth may be edged in thorns but in shadow and light, sorrow and joy I will be there by your side. Although I stand in armor and you in corn silk and lace we become the balance of night and day.

B) The thorns no longer frighten me, they protect the rose. The labyrinth becomes a simple path. In the shadow you stand by me, your inner beauty blinds so strong that I no longer fear being myself. I no longer fear at all. In our balance I see life’s beauty, joy and the future unfold.

K) I come before you of my own free will, to offer my hand, my blade, my heart. My hands are to hold you, my sword to protect you, my heart to love you.

B) I join you here today of my own free will, to offer my hand and my heart. My hand to hold you as we walk side by side, my heart to love you.

K) As long as you will have me.

B) As long as you will have me.

K) As long as the stars shine in the midnight sky

B) As long as the dawn brings the light

K) As long as be both shall choose

B) As long as we both shall choose.

We exchanged rings and drank from a glass of water--as water makes up 90+% of our bodies, the symbol of sharing water represented a merging of who we were, as well as a merging of the universal.

We chose a commitment ceremony for multiple reasons, one to give strength and validity to our relationship in front of our peers and family, another to mark the agreement of commitment to mutual life goals. And...My girlfriend grew up wanting the big white dress and the fairy tale Cinderella wedding--it was one of her biggest childhood dreams and it was good to make that dream day come true for her.

The blending of traditional: white wedding dress, bridesmaids, flower girl, rings; with non- traditional: arch of swords, words as long as we both shall choose from pagan hand-fasting, my choice of clothes was difficult to work out. Originally B. wanted a traditional wedding in the church her mother was married in, with me in a Tux. I wanted a hand-fasting ceremony on the beach with a party afterwards, formal dress optional--come in your renaissance faire gear. The negotiations were long... The house was covered with Modern Bride magazines which spoke to the lack of material for non-traditional weddings/commitments out there.

Coordinating all the aspects of the weddings day was like on a rock concert with a stage show—we did all the work ourselves: cooking, flowers, set up, buring disks of music... “the day of” I spent hours on a walkie talkie working with my “crew” of friends... it was a big project, and we had a large location to set up, run, and clean for the entire day and evening.

It was fun. It was fun to write the vows, craft the ceremony, get websites for flowers, and figure all that out... and it was a fun day.

Having a clear commitment helped us merger tradition and non-tradition.

April 29, 2007

Carolina & Pam's Wedding(s)


On April 19th I had a chance to talk to Carolina about her Marriages to Pam. One was a formal ceremony with Fabulous dresses and lots of friends, and one was in San Francisco, witnessed by another couple who waited in a seven hour line to be married in City Hall. While I don't have the official words from their ceremonies, Carolina told a great tale of how they put their ceremonial wedding together, and what it was like to get legally married.


Their story will follow below...